The Supreme Court's decision to hear Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services puts the legality of President Trump's border proclamation in the spotlight. But the real issue isn't just the executive's power—it's that Congress has failed to define asylum as the privilege it is, with conditions attached.
Asylum is a discretionary grant, not an automatic right. Federal law allows any alien physically present to apply, but the government "may grant" asylum, not must. The distinction is crucial: applying is a statutory right, but receiving asylum is a privilege Congress can shape. The D.C. Circuit's ruling against the administration correctly noted that a president cannot override congressionally established procedures, but that doesn't mean Congress shouldn't reform them.
The current system is broken. With over 3 million active immigration court cases, including 2.3 million asylum claims, the backlog has become a de facto open door. Applicants can wait years, and delay itself becomes the incentive—whether a claim is strong or weak, it buys time in the U.S. This isn't just inefficiency; it's a breeding ground for fraud.
Take the 2022 conviction of a Brooklyn immigration-services executive and attorney for coaching clients to lie in sworn asylum interviews. Every fabricated persecution story pushes a genuine refugee further back in line. The compassionate response is to quickly identify and deport the cheats, not to let the system languish.
Congress must act, not rely on executive proclamations. The Supreme Court's recent ruling in Mullin v. Al Otro Lado—that a migrant in Mexico hasn't arrived—shows the Court is willing to read statutes strictly, but that doesn't solve the underlying problem.
One reform: require asylum grantees to swear an oath renouncing allegiance to their home country upon grant. It's a simple, clear commitment. Another: bar federal means-tested benefits for asylum grantees for ten years. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act already cut SNAP for refugees and asylees; extending that principle to all asylum grantees makes sense.
Critics will call this harsh, citing the Statue of Liberty's poem. But a person fleeing persecution doesn't need food stamps to justify their journey. Genuine refugees accept these terms gladly. Conditions screen for those the statute was truly written for.
This isn't about being cruel; it's about being clear. As Edmund Burke said, society is a partnership across generations, and partners read the terms before signing. Congress should write those terms, pass them, and let the system work. The justices in this case must decide whether a proclamation can do what only a statute should. But the real fix lies with lawmakers, not the courts.
It's time to treat asylum as the privilege it is—one that comes with responsibilities. A country that can't distinguish a true refugee from a freeloader fails both. Congress needs to step up.
