The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a First Amendment challenge to California's requirement that medical licensing courses include instruction on implicit bias, a decision that leaves the mandate in place.
Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Neil Gorsuch voted to hear the case, but the Court's rules require at least four votes to grant review. The denial means the lower court rulings stand, allowing the state to enforce the requirement.
The challenge was brought by Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, an ophthalmologist and frequent instructor of continuing medical education (CME) courses, and Do No Harm, a group that opposes diversity initiatives in medicine. They argued that the mandate forces instructors to convey a “contested ideological message” in violation of their free speech rights.
The First Amendment generally bars the government from compelling private individuals to speak its message, but it does not restrict the government's own speech. The lower courts concluded that the medical courses, which are regulated by the state, constitute government speech and therefore are not subject to the same restrictions.
In a dissent joined by Alito, Thomas wrote that the lower courts' reasoning “fundamentally misunderstands this Court's precedents and the Constitution.” He added, “First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech.” Gorsuch dissented separately without explanation.
California requires licensed physicians to complete at least 50 hours of CME every two years. In 2019, state lawmakers added a requirement that all such courses include curriculum on understanding implicit bias.
Khatibi said she complies with all other state requirements but refuses to include the implicit bias component. Her lawyers urged the justices to review the case, arguing that the lower ruling “erases the constitutional boundary between government and private speech” and conflicts with Supreme Court precedent limiting the government speech doctrine.
California had urged the Court to reject the appeal, arguing that the lower rulings align with precedent and that review would “imperil” medical regulations designed to protect patient health. State officials also warned that accepting the challengers' theory could “transform regulation of the medical profession.”
The denial is a setback for opponents of diversity mandates in medicine, but it does not set a national precedent. The Court's conservative wing has shown interest in such cases, and similar challenges could arise in other states.
This decision comes as the Court has been active on other contentious issues, including gun restrictions and immigration policy. The denial also highlights the ongoing debate over government speech and professional licensing requirements.
