White House counsel Will Scharf on Wednesday informed incoming Democratic committee chairs that their oversight requests from the 119th Congress will not carry over into the next session, effectively requiring them to restart their investigations from scratch. In a letter addressed broadly to “ranking members” of the House and Senate, Scharf argued that the executive branch is under no obligation to respond to inquiries from individual members who lack the authority of a full committee or chamber.
“Your demands do not reflect a request of the House, Senate, or a committee to which that body’s oversight authority has been delegated,” Scharf wrote. “As a result, Ranking Member requests in the 119th Congress do not trigger any obligation to ‘accommodate… the needs of the conflicting branches.’ Although some of you may (or may not) become a Chair in the 120th Congress, that does not mean that requests from the 119th Congress carry over.”
The letter, which was shared with media outlets rather than delivered directly to committee offices, cites a 2017 Office of Legal Counsel opinion from Trump’s first term. That opinion held that “individual members of Congress, including ranking minority members, do not have the authority to conduct oversight in the absence of a specific delegation by a full house, committee, or subcommittee.” Scharf also noted that the Biden administration took the same position in 2022, arguing the precedent is consistent across administrations.
The move is the second time this month that Scharf has pushed back on Democratic oversight plans. Last week, he suggested that Democratic investigations could cross into criminal harassment if they targeted Trump family members or allies. Democrats have dismissed such threats, pointing to the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause, which protects members from executive interference, and federal laws that prohibit obstruction of congressional inquiries.
Democrats have already launched a flurry of investigations during their two years in the minority, probing Trump’s business dealings, cabinet members’ activities, and other matters. On Wednesday, House Oversight ranking member Robert Garcia (D-Calif.) sent a letter to a dozen Trump associates demanding preservation of documents related to ongoing probes. Garcia has framed the work as a legitimate legislative effort to combat corruption and reduce costs for Americans.
“Our work is about taking on government corruption, making life more affordable through bringing down costs by actually going after the crooks and the criminals that are causing harm, and then writing good legislation to stop the corruption from happening in the future,” Garcia said last week on MSNBC. “It’s outrageous that Donald Trump wants to stop any sort of oversight, and certainly he’s trying to stop us members of Congress from doing our job that is in the Constitution.”
The standoff echoes similar clashes during Trump’s first term and Biden’s presidency, when the White House refused to cooperate with minority-party requests. Legal scholars note that courts have generally upheld Congress’s investigative powers, but the practical effect of Scharf’s letter is to force Democrats to re-file their requests once they assume committee chairs in January.
As Democrats prepare to take control of both chambers, the dispute sets the stage for a contentious oversight agenda. The White House’s insistence on starting fresh could delay probes into sensitive areas like Trump’s finances and his administration’s handling of federal agencies. For now, Scharf’s letter signals that the executive branch will not treat previous requests as binding, leaving Democrats to decide whether to escalate the fight.
