With control of Congress in their sights, Democrats are mapping out a strategy to curb President Trump's mass deportation campaign and potentially advance immigration reform. Yet the party is wrestling with how far it can go without alienating voters or provoking a presidential veto.
In the near term, many Democrats want to use their appropriations power to strip funding from Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and impose new restrictions on the agency's operations. They also aim to shield immigrants who lost temporary protected status under Trump's rollbacks. But the bigger question is whether any reform package can win the president's signature.
Representative Veronica Escobar (D-Texas) made an urgent appeal to her colleagues on Wednesday to support a bipartisan bill she co-sponsors with Representative Maria Elvira Salazar (R-Fla.). Escobar argued that a revamped Dignity Act is the only realistic route, saying, “I am a progressive Democrat. I have very aspirational dreams and hopes for immigration reform, but I am also a pragmatist, and … as we continue to have Donald Trump in the White House, and without a supermajority in the Senate, we need Republican support. So, any comprehensive immigration reform must be bipartisan.”
The bill, which has evolved over time, would offer legal status to many undocumented immigrants but no longer includes a pathway to citizenship. That omission troubles many Democrats, including Representative Nanette Díaz Barragán (D-Calif.), who insisted that citizenship is essential. “I think it’s critical that we have a pathway to citizenship,” she said, noting that Trump has tried to strip legal status from even those with protected statuses. “It’s only citizenship that’s going to be the protector for people who’ve been here 10, 20 years.”
At a press conference with business and construction groups, advocates repeatedly urged lawmakers to act sooner rather than later, chanting “fix in ’26” and “don’t wait til ’28.” But the political landscape is fraught. Trump has sent contradictory signals, at times saying he would work with Democrats and even calling some of his immigration policies “too tough,” while also tapping Stephen Miller—the architect of his hardline agenda—as chief of staff. Many Democrats view Miller as a racist and see little hope of productive negotiations.
Representative Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.) voiced deep skepticism, describing Trump as unpredictable. “Trump’s like a very skinny palm blowing in the wind,” she said. “One day he’s like, ‘We were too tough on immigrants.’ The next day he’s like, ‘No amnesty.’ The next day he’s like, ‘Oh I’ll make Stephen Miller my chief of staff,’ which absolutely wipes out any possibility we’re going to do anything good on immigration.” Still, she argued Democrats should press forward: “We need to do what we know to be right. We need to pass it in the House, in the Senate, and then send it to his bill. You never know which Trump we’re going to get.”
Representative Henry Cuellar (D-Texas), who is set to lead the House Appropriations subcommittee on homeland security, has already engaged the White House on curbing ICE. He cautioned against going too far left, citing voter backlash that hurt Democrats in the past. “If you want to focus on criminals, we’re with you 100 percent,” he said, noting that about 70 percent of those detained have no criminal records. “We’re extending our hands out. If they want to work with us, we will work with them. We’re not going to be extreme.”
Senator Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.) suggested a flexible approach, saying Democrats should consider both comprehensive and incremental measures. “If we can pass a big, beautiful conference immigration reform bill, the Trump immigration reform bill—I don’t know if that gets him on our side or not—then let’s do that,” he said. “But if that doesn’t work, then I do think incremental passes to start protecting different communities is also an option.”
The internal debate underscores the challenge Democrats face: balancing their progressive base’s demands with the political necessity of finding common ground with a president who remains in power. As they prepare to take the majority, the party is also eyeing other oversight priorities, including investigations into the administration and regulating AI in political ads. But immigration remains a top concern, and the path forward is anything but clear.
