In the aftermath of Texas voters electing Democrat Gina Hinojosa as governor and flipping the state House, Republican State Rep. Brian Harrison has called on Gov. Greg Abbott to convene a special legislative session. The aim: to overhaul gubernatorial emergency powers so that Hinojosa does not inherit what Harrison describes as "nearly all the powers of a dictator."

Skeptics on the left may view this as a partisan maneuver to weaken an incoming Democratic executive, and there is precedent for such tactics. Yet Harrison, a longtime critic of expansive emergency authority, has a valid point. In Texas and many other states, governors wield sweeping emergency powers that are ripe for misuse. Lawmakers from both parties should set aside partisan instincts and back meaningful reform.

Read also
Politics
GOP lawmakers demand answers as tech outages spark conspiracy concerns
A wave of tech outages has GOP lawmakers demanding answers and the White House to reassure the public, with some suggesting the failures may not be coincidental.

Emergency powers are a necessary tool, but they carry inherent risks. Crises like natural disasters, pandemics, or civil unrest demand swift action that legislatures often cannot provide. Consequently, federal and state laws grant executives exceptional latitude to act beyond normal statutory bounds. The danger lies in the absence of robust checks.

At the federal level, Congress has largely delegated the determination of what constitutes an emergency to the president. Beyond informal norms, few safeguards prevent a chief executive from invoking emergency powers to bypass Congress on policy disputes. The most potent authorities—such as seizing control of communications, freezing assets without judicial review, or regulating domestic transportation—could be weaponized to consolidate power and suppress dissent.

State-level powers are even more concerning. Many states allow governors to suspend laws governing state operations, shut down businesses, restrict movement, ban public assemblies, and even commandeer private property. While states do possess broad "police power" to protect public health and safety, the lack of oversight is troubling. Some states impose time limits on emergency declarations absent legislative approval, but most permit governors to renew them unilaterally and indefinitely.

Abuse of emergency powers is a bipartisan phenomenon. In 2019, President Trump declared a national emergency to fund a border wall; in 2022, President Biden used emergency authority to cancel student debt. Both actions stretched the law to address policy goals that Congress had not enacted. The most egregious historical examples—the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II and post-9/11 detainee torture—occurred under presidents of both parties.

Governors have also overstepped. During the pandemic, Michigan's legislature refused to extend Gov. Gretchen Whitmer's emergency declaration, so she issued a new one the next day—a blatant end-run around legislative authority. In Texas, Abbott has renewed his border disaster declaration 69 times since 2021, even as unlawful crossings have plummeted over the past 20 months.

These bipartisan abuses have fueled rare cross-aisle cooperation in Congress. A leading proposal would require presidentially declared emergencies to expire after 30 days unless Congress approves an extension. In September 2024, the measure passed a Senate committee 13-1 and a House committee unanimously. Though the current administration has stalled progress, its broad support suggests eventual passage.

Harrison's Texas plan mirrors this federal approach, including the 30-day limit and legislative ratification. It also adds provisions for narrowly tailored orders and expedited judicial review. These are sensible enhancements that could serve as a model for other states.

For reform to succeed and endure, it must be framed as a fundamental separation-of-powers issue, not a partisan power grab. The political landscape is shifting, and both parties have incentives to restrain executive overreach. As the federal permitting reform push has shown, bipartisan coalitions can advance structural changes when the stakes are clear. Texas lawmakers should seize this moment to enact lasting safeguards.