California has taken a significant step toward reforming how long prison sentences are reviewed, with new regulations that took effect on October 1. The state's Board of Parole Hearings finalized rules that require a periodic reassessment of whether individuals serving lengthy terms still need to be incarcerated. Under the new framework, any incarcerated person becomes eligible for a sentence reconsideration after completing 25 years of continuous imprisonment.

The regulations introduce what advocates call a "second look" process, extending even to those serving life without parole, though they do not create parole eligibility where none exists. The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation explains that the process provides "the courts and the governor with an expert assessment of an incarcerated person's risk to public safety before they make any prison release decision." Inmates who meet certain criteria will be automatically scheduled for review.

Read also
Policy
Supreme Court declines to hear challenge to California's implicit bias training for doctors
The Supreme Court declined to hear a free-speech challenge to California's requirement that doctors receive implicit bias training, with three conservative justices dissenting.

Why Second Look Matters

Governors have long been reluctant to grant clemency to individuals serving life without parole, often assuming that their release would pose a danger to society. However, research suggests that this assumption is flawed. A report from the Sentencing Project notes that "most criminal careers are under 10 years, and as people age, they usually desist from crime," adding that "a robust body of empirical literature shows that people released after decades of imprisonment, including for murder, have low recidivism rates."

The cost of keeping aging prisoners behind bars is also a factor. States spend an average of more than $33,000 per inmate per year, and that figure rises with age due to increased medical needs. In 2022, the American Bar Association urged states to adopt "second look" policies that allow judicial review of sentences at designated times to determine if they remain appropriate.

How the Process Works

California's regulations establish a multi-step review. A hearing officer with expertise in risk assessment meets with the incarcerated person, reviews all relevant information, and decides whether to refer the case for a hearing. The officer can make a referral "if it is reasonably likely that the person will receive a recommendation for a commutation and resentencing."

If referred, a forensic psychologist conducts a "Comprehensive Risk Assessment" focusing on whether the individual "poses a high risk of future violence." If the psychologist finds such risk, the process ends, and the inmate becomes eligible for another review in three years. If the risk is deemed low, a formal hearing is scheduled with the Board of Parole Hearings.

Even if the board recommends a sentence reconsideration or commutation, the recommendation is reviewed by its legal division and then forwarded to the governor or the sentencing judge, who retain full discretion to accept, modify, or ignore it. And neither commutation nor resentencing guarantees release.

Legal Challenge

The regulations face a legal challenge. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation sued last summer, arguing that the Board of Parole Hearings lacked authority to issue the rules without legislative or voter approval. The group contends that courts have already determined that certain sentences warrant life without parole or terms exceeding 28 years. CBS News reports that the state defends the regulations as merely establishing a process for preparing public safety risk assessments for courts and the governor.

The court has not yet ruled. Supporters, including legal scholars, view California's move as a long-overdue reform that brings new resources and expertise to bear on sentence review decisions, and they hope other states will follow suit.