Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.) has sharply criticized Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick for what she calls a failure to safeguard America's competitive edge in artificial intelligence, accusing the department of allowing advanced AI chips to reach China despite repeated warnings from federal officials.
In a letter dispatched Sunday, Cantwell, the top Democrat on the Senate Commerce Committee, pressed Lutnick to tighten export controls and highlighted the department's inaction regarding a Singapore-based company suspected of funneling sensitive U.S. technology to Beijing. She wrote, "America cannot maintain its leadership in AI if the agency responsible for protecting that advantage fails to enforce its own controls."
The rebuke arrives as Lutnick prepares to accompany President Trump to China later this week for the APEC summit. It also follows public criticism from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who said his department, along with State, Defense, and the U.S. Trade Representative, had backed blacklisting Megaspeed International for months—only to be met with resistance from Commerce.
Megaspeed drew scrutiny after reports surfaced of an extramarital affair between Alice Huang, a former executive suspected by U.S. intelligence of being a Chinese spy, and former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang. Cantwell argued that Commerce's decision to suspend its own investigation left the company free to continue acquiring advanced AI chips, directly undermining national security.
"Despite these warnings, the Department of Commerce delayed action on repeated national security warnings, putting America's technological advantage in AI at risk," Cantwell wrote.
Bessent, during a CNBC interview on Friday, pointed the finger squarely at Commerce: "Commerce has the pen, and you will have to ask them about their internal processes. My deputy has been pushing this for months."
Cantwell also raised concerns about potential financial conflicts, noting that Cantor Fitzgerald—the firm Lutnick led for decades and which is now controlled by his sons—held $1.2 billion in Nvidia stock at the time of his nomination. She warned, "America's national security and AI leadership cannot be compromised by family business interests or a policy that generates federal revenue from exporting technology critical to our competitive edge."
The Commerce Department has not yet responded to requests for comment. The controversy underscores growing bipartisan unease over export enforcement, even as Democrats push for stricter oversight. For more on the broader political dynamics, see Democrats' big win masks a fragile coalition.
As the APEC summit approaches, the dispute between Cantwell and Lutnick highlights the tension between economic interests and security imperatives, a theme that resonates in Trump's planned talks with Xi. Meanwhile, Democrats are also eyeing new AI regulations in political advertising, reflecting broader concerns about the technology's impact.
