President Trump's final two years in office are shaping up to be defined not just by policy battles but by his aggressive legal war on the press. After a string of high-profile defamation losses, including a costly verdict he has twice appealed to the Supreme Court, Trump has now secured two significant court victories that could leave a lasting imprint on defamation law.
On the eve of ABC reportedly suspending reporters involved in an alleged hit piece on his family, Trump won rulings in Florida allowing defamation claims against both The New York Times and the BBC to proceed to trial. These decisions, if upheld, could set important precedents for how courts treat media liability in politically charged cases.
The first ruling, by U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday, greenlit four of seven claims in Trump's $15 billion lawsuit against the Times. The case centers on a 2023 article by Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, "Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success," which suggested possible criminal tax fraud or money laundering without a formal legal basis. Merryday questioned the paper's reliance on three experts—Lee-Ford Tritt, Adam S. Kaufmann, and Mitchell Gans—whose statements like "smells like a crime" and "highly suspicious" actions were deemed insufficient to support the article's insinuations.
The judge criticized the Times for publishing what he called a "superficial characterization" of criminal conduct without a "thorough examination of pertinent facts." He noted that the reporters "know that they don't know, but they are undeterred," and that such conduct could constitute "the purposeful avoidance of the truth, a knowing failure that remains actionable, even after Times v. Sullivan." This case directly challenges the "actual malice" standard from the landmark 1964 Supreme Court decision, which requires public figures to prove knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth.
In a separate ruling, Judge Jeffrey Kuntz allowed Trump's lawsuit against the BBC to move forward. The case stems from a documentary aired just before the 2024 election, "Trump: A Second Chance," which spliced together two lines from Trump's January 6, 2021 speech that were delivered 55 minutes apart. The edited segment made it appear Trump had said, "We're going to walk down to the Capitol, and I'll be there with you. And we fight. We fight like hell..."—while omitting his explicit call for supporters to go "peacefully" and his earlier remarks about cheering on lawmakers.
The BBC's own journalists admitted the editing violated basic ethical standards, as the spliced lines created a false impression. Trump's legal team argues this constitutes reckless disregard for the truth, a key element under existing defamation law. The case highlights the growing scrutiny of media editing practices in the digital age.
These victories come amid broader debates over press freedom and accountability. While some legal experts warn that allowing such cases to proceed could chill investigative journalism, Trump and his allies argue that the media must be held to higher standards. The outcomes could influence how courts interpret New York Times v. Sullivan, a decision Trump has long criticized as giving the press too much leeway.
As these cases head to trial, they could redefine the boundaries of defamation law, particularly for public figures. With Trump's legal team pressing for clarification of "actual malice," the stakes are high for media organizations nationwide. For more on how these rulings fit into the broader political landscape, see Trump's defensive press conference and Senate GOP judicial confirmation race.
