The Justice Department has quietly expanded the portfolio of Bill Essayli, a California-based federal prosecutor already under a legal cloud, assigning him to the high-stakes Florida inquiry examining past investigations into President Trump. The move comes as that probe has hemorrhaged senior personnel and faces mounting questions about its direction.

Essayli currently serves as the first assistant U.S. attorney for the Central District of California, a position he has held beyond the 120-day limit permitted for temporary appointments. A federal judge last month ruled that his continued service in that role was unlawful, casting a shadow over his authority. Despite that setback, the DOJ confirmed that Essayli will now also take on duties in the Southern District of Florida, where the review into the 2022 search of Mar-a-Lago and other matters involving the president is based.

Read also
Politics
DeSantis dismisses Supreme Court seat, targeting 2028 run
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis dismissed interest in a Supreme Court seat, calling justices 'potted plants,' and left the door open for a 2028 presidential run.

The Florida probe has been a revolving door for prosecutors. Joe diGenova, a Trump ally who had stepped in to lead the effort, resigned in September, citing concerns about the pace and integrity of the investigation. In an interview with the New York Post at the time, diGenova warned, “If you want indictments where there’s no evidence, you have an ethical problem.”

His departure followed that of Maria Medetis Long, a career DOJ official who had been a leading figure in the case. Long resigned in April, reportedly over doubts about the strength of the evidence. Jason Reding Quiñones, who had served as the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Florida, also stepped down shortly after the midterm elections, leaving the probe without steady leadership.

The assignment of Essayli adds another layer of controversy to an already fraught process. His current role has been challenged in court, and his new responsibilities come as the DOJ faces scrutiny over its handling of politically sensitive investigations. Critics argue that placing a prosecutor with a contested appointment at the helm of such a consequential review undermines its credibility.

Essayli has been a visible figure in the department’s clash with California over voter rolls, where he has pushed counties to remove alleged noncitizens from registration lists. He has described the DOJ’s request as “simple” and vowed to hold election officials accountable if they fail to comply. That hardline stance has made him a polarizing figure, and his new role in Florida is likely to draw further attention.

The Florida probe is separate from the broader constitutional battles over Trump's legal exposure, but it remains a flashpoint in the ongoing fight over how the justice system handles the president. The review was initially launched to examine the FBI’s search of Mar-a-Lago and has since expanded to other issues, though its scope and goals have been murky.

Legal experts note that the staffing turmoil could complicate any eventual findings. With diGenova and Long both raising concerns about evidentiary standards, the probe’s credibility is already under fire. Essayli’s appointment may do little to reassure skeptics, especially given his own legal troubles.

The DOJ has not commented on how Essayli’s dual roles will be managed or whether his legal status in California will affect his work in Florida. For now, the department appears to be pressing forward, even as the investigation continues to lose key players. The situation remains fluid, and further resignations or legal challenges could reshape the probe’s trajectory.

This is not the first time the DOJ has faced criticism over its handling of politically charged cases. The political battles over oversight and judicial appointments have intensified, and the Florida probe is likely to remain a point of contention. As the investigation continues, all eyes will be on Essayli and whether he can steer it through the storm.