In a dramatic turn on Capitol Hill, the absence of 11 Democratic lawmakers last week effectively derailed an impeachment push against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, handing the embattled Pentagon chief an unexpected reprieve. The procedural vote, which sent the impeachment resolution back to committee, passed 211 to 204—a margin that would have flipped had Democrats shown up and voted with their colleagues.

The near-miss came just days after House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) told ABC that impeaching Hegseth was a “hard yes,” signaling strong Democratic support for removal. But when the roll was called, a dozen members of the caucus were absent, allowing Republicans to table the measure and indefinitely delay any full House vote.

Read also
Politics
GOP lawmakers demand answers as tech outages spark conspiracy concerns
A wave of tech outages has GOP lawmakers demanding answers and the White House to reassure the public, with some suggesting the failures may not be coincidental.

The resolution, authored by Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.), accused Hegseth of eight impeachable offenses, including waging unauthorized war against Iran and Yemen, conducting lethal strikes on suspected drug-smuggling vessels in Latin America that included secondary attacks on survivors, and retaliating against Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) for public criticism. The articles also cited Hegseth’s removal of top military officers over diversity, equity, and inclusion concerns, and his six-month suspension of Pentagon press briefings, which critics said evaded accountability for failures in the Iranian war effort.

Democratic lawmakers and progressive commentators expressed outrage at the missed opportunity. Some pointed fingers at Jeffries, accusing him of failing to whip enough votes. Jeffries, who called Hegseth “the most unqualified secretary of defense in American history,” stopped short of explicitly endorsing impeachment, saying only that “we’ll have that conversation” about another attempt next year.

Even if the House had voted to impeach, conviction in the Senate would have required a two-thirds majority—a high bar that would have necessitated support from roughly a dozen Republicans in the incoming Democratic-controlled chamber. Still, the procedural defeat was a blow to those who hoped to force a public reckoning before the new Congress convenes in January 2027.

Hegseth, who has faced mounting criticism from across the political spectrum, defended himself defiantly at a Pentagon press briefing, vowing, “I stand behind every one of these operations. I was proud to execute them, and I would do it again tomorrow.” His comments drew sharp rebukes from Democrats, who argue his actions constitute unlawful conduct and a abuse of power.

The vote unfolded against a backdrop of sweeping Republican losses in the midterms, which had left many GOP lawmakers wary of backing a controversial figure. Seven Republicans also skipped the vote, but their absence was less consequential than the Democrats’ no-shows. Some Republicans who had privately expressed dissatisfaction with Hegseth ultimately argued that impeachment was not the proper remedy, noting that he serves at the pleasure of the president.

Vice President JD Vance dismissed the impeachment effort as “political theater,” asking rhetorically, “Has Pete Hegseth committed impeachable crimes? The question is absurd and the answer is: obviously not.” But with Democrats set to take control of Congress next year, Hegseth’s reprieve may be temporary. As Jeffries and other Democrats weigh their next move, the defense secretary’s future remains uncertain.